Skip to Content

The Best Non-Toxic Muffin Pan to Eliminate Toxins

Feel free to share

The Best Non-Toxic Muffin Pan for Your Baked Treats

Whether you love making light and fluffy blueberry muffins, or you’re cooking up a batch of cupcakes for a party, you don’t want toxic chemicals getting into your food. Unfortunately, that might be happening if you’re not using a non-toxic muffin pan.

While it sounds scary, the good news is that it’s really easy to avoid these dangerous chemicals. You simply need to make the switch to one of these top non-toxic muffin pans.

Read on to learn more about the toxic chemicals that might be hiding in your muffin pan. Then discover the best non-toxic muffin pan you can start using today to ensure all of your treats are safe to eat.

Why Is it Important to Use a Non-Toxic Muffin Pan?

Chocolate muffins in muffin pan

We’ve already talked about the importance of choosing non-toxic cookware for making your meals and non-toxic baking sheets for your cookies and sheet dinners. But what about a non-toxic muffin pan? Do we have to worry about toxins entering our food when we use regular muffin pans?

Unfortunately, certain types of muffin pans can have coatings that contain toxic chemicals that leach into our food. The two worst muffin pan materials are certain types of non-stick coatings and aluminum.

Certain Non-Stick Coatings

While a nonstick coating might make it easy to get food out, many types can contain hazardous substances such as PFOA and PFAS, especially those made before 2015.

PFAS are the chemicals used to make Teflon non-stick. They’re also known as “forever chemicals.” As their name suggests, once PFAS chemicals get into the environment or the human body, they’re impossible to get rid of.

Exposure to PFAS has been linked to a variety of health concerns, including certain types of cancers, liver damage, infertility, birth defects, thyroid disease, high cholesterol, and obesity. Plus, if you use cookware and bakeware coated in PFAS on high heat, they can release toxic fumes that can cause lung damage.


Exposure to high levels of aluminum has been linked to certain health disorders of the nervous system, such as Alzheimer’s disease. This is one reason why some people are opting to ditch conventional deodorants that contain aluminum and make the switch to effective natural deodorants.

Fortunately, not all aluminum pans are bad. The most concerning ones are untreated aluminum, which can leach harmful chemicals into your food when heated.

The safer alternative is hard-anodized aluminum cookware. Anodized aluminum bakeware is sealed so the metal can’t leach into food or react with acidic foods.

The Best Non-Stick Muffin Pan for Perfect Cupcakes and Muffins

Now that you know why it’s so important to make the switch to a non-toxic muffin tin, be sure to check out these top options to choose the style that will work best for your baking needs. Not only will these muffin pans keep your food safe to eat, but they’ll also deliver outstanding results each and every time you use them!

1. Caraway

Caraway muffin pan

Caraway has an outstanding collection of ceramic cookware and bakeware. All of their items feature a non-toxic, durable, naturally slick ceramic coating that makes healthy cooking and clean up easier than ever.

Their muffin pan has a non-stick and non-toxic coating that’s free of heavy metals, lead, cadmium, PFOAs, PFAs, and PTFEs. This mineral-based coating won’t leach toxic materials into your food.

Their ceramic bakeware provides consistent heat distribution for evenly cooked food and is oven safe up to 550°F. Plus, you know your baked goods will release smoothly and cleaning up is incredibly simple.

Related: Must-Have Eco-Friendly Kitchen Products You’ll Absolutely Love

Caraway pieces are also better for you and better for the planet. That’s because they release less carbon dioxide when produced compared to traditional non-stick coatings.

You can purchase the muffin pan separately in a variety of different colors. You can also consider a Caraway bakeware set for a complete collection.

This 5-piece set includes 2 baking sheets, a muffin pan, a rectangle pan, and cabinet organizers. Or opt for the 11-piece set, which comes with 2 baking sheets, a muffin pan, a rectangle pan, a square pan, a loaf pan, 2 circle pans, and a cooling rack.

2. GreenLife

The GreenLife muffin pan is made from heavy-duty steel for fast and even heat distribution. It’s then coated with a healthy, easy-to-clean ceramic non-stick coating that’s free of PFAS, PFOA, lead, and cadmium for trouble-free cooking and quick cleanup.

Your muffins and cupcakes will pop right out without leaving half behind or leaving a big mess that’s hard to remove.

Related: How to Make Your Kitchen More Eco-Friendly in Just 9 Easy Steps

The pan features reinforced rims to enhance its strength and stability so you can enjoy using it for years and years. It’s also oven safe up to 450°F.

If you need a complete set for your kitchen, GreenLife also offers a 12-piece baking set that comes with 2 cookie sheets, a loaf pan, 2 round cake pans, a 12-cup muffin pan, 4 baking utensils, and measuring spoons.

3. Lodge Cast Iron

Yes, it’s true. The same company that makes your favorite cast iron skillet also offers a muffin pan! You have your choice of either a Lodge cast iron 6-well muffin pan or a 7-well mini cake pan.

These pans provide edge-to-edge even heat distribution. While this is great for consistent baking and browning, it also means you have to remember that the entire pan will heat up when it’s in the oven.

That’s why it’s also a good idea to pick up some silicone assist handles to provide a secure and comfortable grip when you’re handling the bakeware.

You’ll be please to know that every piece is also pre-seasoned with 100% vegetable oil and ready to use right out of the box. Can’t you just imagine the tasty muffins, cornbread, and more you can make in these pans?

Related: How to Green Clean Your Entire House With Homemade Natural Cleaning Products

No matter which Lodge cast iron pieces you decide to get, you’ll enjoy strong and durable heirloom-quality pans that won’t bend, dent, or warp, which means you can keep them in the family for generations to come.

Plus, you can feel confident that you’re getting a quality muffin pan that’s still made in the United States. That’s because Lodge has manufactured its cast iron cookware in South Pittsburg, Tennessee, since 1896.

4. Fox Run

This lightweight muffin pan from Fox Run is made with sleek stainless steel that’s scratch-, stain-, and rust-resistant. It’s also long-lasting because it won’t warp or corrode.

This pan doesn’t use Teflon or non-stick coatings, so you never have to worry about it releasing toxic fumes into the air or leaching dangerous chemicals into your food. Plus, since stainless steel is a non-reactive metal, it can withstand high temperatures and is an excellent heat conductor.

Related: Are There Toxins Hiding in Your Cleaning Products?

This stainless steel muffin pan is so easy to clean it’s actually dishwasher safe!

In addition to the traditional 12-cup muffin pan, Fox Run also offers a 6-cup muffin pan and a 24-cup mini muffin pan. With so many sizes and options available, you’ll have no problems finding the best muffin pan to suit all of your baking needs!

5. casaWare

The durable and long-lasting muffin pan from casaWare is made with a carbon steel base and a non-stick ceramic coating. Not only does this double-coated ceramic surface mean your baked goods will easily release from the pan, but it also means cleaning up is completely painless.

Additionally, you can rest easy knowing this coating is free of cadmium, lead, PFOA, PTFE, and PFOS. It’s also approved by the FDA, California Proposition 65 compliant, and approved by the European Union.

The pans are heat tolerant up to 450°F and they won’t peel or blister in high temperatures.

Related: The Best Non-Toxic and Plastic-Free Food Storage Containers

Like other non-stick pans, you don’t want to use metal utensils or sharp objects on this muffin pan because it might scratch the surface. Instead, always make sure you remove your items before cutting or slicing. Also, be sure to use silicone utensils or wooden utensils when removing food from the pan.

Along with the conventional 12-cup muffin pan in several bright and cheerful colors, you can also get a 6-cup toaster oven muffin pan that’s the perfect compact size to fit in your toaster oven. Of course, this muffin pan will still work seamlessly in your conventional oven.

6. Silpat

Silicone has recently gotten a bad reputation because manufacturers were cutting corners and filling their silicone with other chemical-leaching components. In order to stay safe, you always want to look for 100% pure food-grade silicone.

One great option to consider is this Silpat Perfect Muffin Mold. You don’t have to use any extra butter, grease, oils, or sprays because your muffins will pop right out of the non-stick silicone molds.

Related: Enjoy a Zero Waste Cup of Tea With the Top Reusable Tea Bags

The silicone muffin pan has 12 molds so you can make a perfect dozen of your favorite baked goods. To use, simply place the muffin pan on a baking sheet, fill each mold with your batter, and place it in the oven.

Not only does silicone let your food release cleanly and easily, but it also means cleaning up is a breeze. Plus, if you ever need to freeze leftovers or make perfectly portioned tomato sauce, you’ll be pleased to know that silicone is freezer safe!

7. Boxiki

This Boxiki muffin pan is another great choice if you’re interested in silicone. The muffin pan features easy-to-release silicone baking cups in a durable, high-quality steel frame.

It comes with wide handles that provide a firm and secure grip when you’re taking the pan in and out of the oven. The entire muffin pan resists sagging, bending, and warping while still providing maximum stain and odor resistance. This pan is also dishwasher, freezer, and oven safe up to 420°F.

Related: The Best Sustainable Dish Soap for Naturally Clean Dishes

Silicone doesn’t need any extra butter or oil since it’s already non-stick. However, you can still use a light coating of cooking spray if you want to add some extra flavor to your baked goods.

Boxiki offers several different styles of muffin pans. In addition to the 12-cup pan with a steel frame, they also have a 6-cup muffin pan with silicone liners and a 12-cup mini muffin pan with silicone liners.

Plus, the possibilities of what you can cook with the pans are endless. You can enjoy making muffins, cupcake, tarts, mini omelets, mini pot pies, and more!

8. Le Creuset

You might be familiar with Le Creuset because of its enameled cast iron cookware, but did you know the company also has a great selection of bakeware? That selection includes this 12-cup muffin tray.

This strong, rigid muffin pan will not bend, warp, or twist while you’re using it. It features a durable, PFOA-free non-stick coating on the inside and outside so your food simply slides out with ease.

The tray also comes with silicone inserts on each end for added grip and a more secure hold. It’s oven safe up to 400°F and comes with a lifetime guarantee.

Related: How These Compostable Pods Can Make a More Sustainable Cup of Coffee

9. All-Clad

You can use this 12-cup All-Clad muffin pan to make everything from cupcakes and muffins to egg cups and mini pot pies.

The muffin pan features generously sized handles that give you plenty of room to hold it with oven mitts without touching your food. It also has rounded corners and a lighter color to help prevent too much browning.​

Related: How to Start a Zero Waste Meal Prep Routine in 4 Simple Steps

The heavy gauge alloy steel offers superior heat conduction for uniform baking. Plus, not only does the ceramic-reinforced, PFOA-free nonstick coating provide an easy release, but it also helps resist stains and scratches.

This muffin pan is oven safe up to 450°F and includes a limited lifetime warranty.

What Should You Do if You Have an Old Muffin Pan?

What if you have an old muffin pan that you suspect is made with aluminum or has a non-stick PFAS coating and you want to reduce your exposure to those harmful chemicals? If you don’t want to swap it out for a new muffin pan right away, we recommend using natural paper liners.

Natural paper liners help you avoid chemicals that could be present in aluminum liners. Additionally, they’re odorless, unbleached, and food-grade to protect your family’s health.

The Best Non-Toxic Muffin Pans to Keep Your Baked Goods Safe

You don’t want nasty chemicals ending up in the food you make. That’s why it’s important to ensure you’re using a safe non-stick muffin pan.

Fortunately, it’s very easy to find the perfect muffin pan to suit all of your needs when you select one of these best non-toxic muffin pans.

More Helpful Eco-Friendly Tips

Did you enjoy learning more about the best non-toxic muffin pan? Are you interested in discovering even more tips that can help you live a sustainable life? Then please be sure to take a look at some of our other popular posts:

Get updates on the latest posts and more from Earth Friendly Tips straight to your inbox.

* indicates required

Please select all the ways you would like to hear from Earth Friendly Tips:

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. For information about our privacy practices, please visit our website.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp’s privacy practices here.

Picture of muffin pan with chocolate muffins with text overlay The Best Non-Toxic Muffin Pans and Why It's so Crucial to Switch
Picture of muffin pan with ingredients for preparing pastries on table and homemade chocolate muffins in a muffin tin with text overlay 9 Eco-Friendly and Non-Toxic Muffin Pans for Safer Baking
Picture of chocolate muffins in muffin tin with text overlay Why You Need to Switch to a Non-Toxic Muffin Pan Right Away